DIY Home Improvement, Remodeling & Repair Forum

DIY Home Improvement, Remodeling & Repair Forum (
-   Water Softener and Heater (
-   -   Funny smell in the water (

brasilmom 06-07-2010 12:07 PM

Funny smell in the water
Hi all,

Lately I have noticed that our water (mostly during shower) is smelling a bit like sulfur. Now, we do not have well, and are supplied by city water. I mostly notice the smell in the shower, but also in the laundry. So, I am wondering i there is a way to flush, clean and disinfect the water softener and also the water heater. Our water heater is not all that new and may be looking into getting replaced in 2 years or so. Then, we may consider an on-demand water heater. For now, it would be very nice not to smell sulfur during showers.

Thanks for any help you can provide. Be well


frozenstar 06-08-2010 10:14 PM

Haven't experience that. Have you asked your water supplier if they did anything? Wondering if you can put on a water filter.

handyguys 06-09-2010 11:15 AM

Is it hot water only? Do you smell it in water from the hose? This is often caused by stuff in the water heater. If you are on city water and its hot water only thats what I would suspect.

An easy (hopefully) first step would be to flush the water heater. If its old you could run into issues with not being able to open the valve at the bottom and/or the bottom is filled with sediment and the tank wont drain. If the tank wont drain then, well. Start saving for that new water heater and my guess would be the smell would go away.

Dont let some water treatment expert sell you an expensive treatment system, I dont think thats whats called for. The draining the tank is a zero cost solution that may fix it.

Speedbump 06-10-2010 07:09 AM

Like mentioned before, it it's only in the hot, it's the heater's sacrificial rod that is probably causing the smell.

If it's in the cold also, then you may not have a softener, you may have a carbon filter. They can foul and start growing bacteria which can cause a sulplur odor. Do you add salt to a container for your softener?

It could also be that your near the end of the run on the water supply and the chlorine isn't getting to your home. Bacteria growth can certainly cause an odor.

kok328 06-10-2010 02:58 PM

Process of elimination; bypass the water softener for a few days and see if it still smells like rotten eggs.

brasilmom 06-13-2010 07:28 PM

Ok, we were able to figure it out. The problem was indeed the water heater. We drained some of the water so we could add chlorine to disinfect. Then, the rod was removed and replaced. The rod was completely rotten. After the disinfecting we ran all the faucets and showers in the house to clean the lines as well. It has filled back up and the odor is now gone. Thanks all for helping out.

Be we,


brasilmom 09-12-2010 07:25 PM

Well, some time went by and we were enjoying shower without funky smell. Unfortunately it was short lived. The smell is back and since it has been just three months that we replaced the rod and disinfect the water heater, I feel that its time is come to an end. Is that what I am contemplating? That being the case, I would like to learn more about tankless water heater. Can anyone here give me some education on that?
Thanks. Be well


Speedbump 09-13-2010 07:19 AM

I'm wondering what rod you replaced the old one with. There are different rods. Some cause the odor, others don't. The odor is bacteria. If replacing the rod doesn't help, you can crank up the temperature to 140 and the smell will go away. The bacteria can't live in 140 temperatures.

Charcoal filters like you buy in big box stores are good temporary measures and that's about all they are good for. Carbon only takes out a hint of sulphur odor and is easily and quickly used up. Don't waste you money. Fix the problem. If it's the water heater, get another type of rod, or just remove it.

brasilmom 09-19-2010 06:51 PM

Well, I do not know what rod was used to replace the old one. However, I did follow your advice about getting a higher temperature, and voila, the funny (not) smell is gone! Thanks for the help. Be well


brasilmom 10-27-2010 06:18 AM

Just as a follow up. The smell did return fast and furious. We did the following: we once again empty the water heater. Removed the plug on the lower part of the water heater so any sediments could come out. We got a lot out. We did gushes of cold water to help the sediments out. We then filed half up and add about 4 pints of peroxide. We flushed all the lines before filling it up again. Flushed again and now it is running like new. We may do the peroxide treatment one more time to provide a deeper cleaning to the lines. Thanks for all the help you are able to provide me. Be well

All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:24 AM.