notmrjohn, I had been considering galvanized panels, but I had been a bit hesitant because of what
Precision Home Services and
BridgeMan mention, the reduction of light. But, I could do with a little less light, since I have windows galore in that room. I'm a bit ambivalent about the light issue, actually.
nealtw, what do you mean by strapping? I tried to look it up but couldn't find it. Is that the wavy underside that keeps them in shape? Foam closure strips? If so, the polycarbonate that I'm looking into is not exactly wavy, it is more angular:
Suntuf 26 in. x 12 ft. Clear Polycarbonate Roofing Panel Would they still work?
But, one thing that galvanized panels have on their side is that they seem to be cheaper.
Thanks guys, since I didn't hear any horror stories from you, I'll assume that the choice is just up to taste