I agree with your wife. However, if this is a spare bathroom and you have another bathroom with a tub, then I agree with you. We just had a tub to shower conversion done in our second bathroom which is great! We had ReBath do it which wasn't so great! But it has clear shower doors and it really looks nice. However, if you are going to use ReBath...don't pay them until you like the way it looks. For the price it should have been perfect, but we had to call them back 4 times to correct problems. I did complain and they are coming next week with the supervisor to inspect it. But it really does look nice.