DIY Home Improvement, Remodeling & Repair Forum > DIY Home Improvement > Electrical and Wiring > AFCI vs GFCI Receptacle for Bedroom




Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old 02-09-2014, 01:53 PM  
curtish
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2014
Posts: 3
Default AFCI vs GFCI Receptacle for Bedroom

Hi,

I have an older house built 1938 which has mostly 2-wire BX wiring throughout.

I plan on replacing a few polarized 2-prong outlets to 3-prong... and was considering an AFCI receptacle for added safety. I read that some new construction requires this and also because my daughter uses her hair dryer and curling irons in her room I feel that I'd like the extra protection from circuit overloading / fire... with the older house wiring. The outlets I would be replacing with an AFCI are all BX wire with metal boxes.

My thinking is to us an AFCI receptacle for added safety but then I was reading information that seemed to suggest there were other considerations with how the house was wired from a branch, etc.

QUESTION: is it appropriate to use a AFCI in a bedroom for this purpose?
QUESTION: Should I use an AFCI over a GFCI? Think I saw on this old house once where they used a GFI in a bedroom.

Thanks!



__________________

Last edited by curtish; 02-09-2014 at 01:55 PM.
curtish is offline  
 
Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 02-09-2014, 02:53 PM  
speedy petey
Lic.Electrical Contractor
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 445
Liked 39 Times on 27 Posts
Likes Given: 17

Default

Neither AFCI nor GFCI will protect from overload or short circuit. This is the job of the breaker.

Now...GFI on ungrounded circuits DOES provide an added level of safety, AND on the LOAD side of a GFI breaker or receptacle you can install 3-prong receptacles. This is a code complaint alternative to re-wiring.
That said, AFCI will provide an even additional level of safety, but with such older wiring you may get more than normal nuisance tripping.
If you want it all, you can use an AFCI breaker, and a GFI receptacle at the first receptacle in the circuit. One major problem I find in this scenario is that many older homes like yours are wired in such a way that there is a junction box, typically in a basement light or box in the attic, and the rest of the circuit continues from there with several legs. Similar to a wagon wheel hub and spokes. With this wiring setup you CANNOT use the LINE and LOAD function of a GFI receptacle. You'd need a GFI at nearly every spot.
Using a GFI breaker, and NOT an AFCI at all would solve this problem and still add a decent level of safety over what you have now..



__________________
speedy petey is offline  
3
People Like This 
Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 02-10-2014, 08:33 AM  
Wuzzat?
Banned
 
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 2,328
Liked 167 Times on 154 Posts
Likes Given: 94

Default

My wife has a hair dryer with a GFCI built into the plug and the wall outlet is also a GFCI. So, with these two GFCIs cascaded we get nuisance tripping - but - always with the wall outlet and never with the dryer plug.

I guess the dryer plug is less sensitive or maybe it doesn't work at all.
Testing the plug GFCI would require me to run a 16 kilo-ohm resistor from the dryer insides to a ground. Since we already have a GFCI in the wall this is a pretty low priority job for me.

Anyway, since organizations are somewhat less likely to BS the Patent Office than the general public
I'd do an online search for patents for GFCI designs that specifically address this tripping problem and
hopefully you can find a GFCI in a store nearby that incorporates the improved design.
But, everybody wants to use up old stock first.

__________________
Wuzzat? is offline  
 
Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 02-10-2014, 11:21 AM  
curtish
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2014
Posts: 3
Default

Thanks guys,

I hear what you are saying but I don't fully understand why an AFCI Receptacle is of no value over a GFI in this situation... (by the way, the curling iron does not have a GFI oddly enough)

I get that the AFCI can't prevent a circuit overload and that would be the function of the circuit breaker.

EDIT: It occurred to me that I may be confusing two different kinds of AFCIs. As you know, there are Outlet AFCI Receptacles and AFCI Breakers. I was considering a Outlet AFCI Receptacle...

QUESTION: What is the proper use of an AFCI receptacle? Should I just be replacing my breaker with a AFCI breaker instead?

If I can get a AFCI Breaker to replace my SQUARE D breaker, should I assume that would protect the entire circuit? that would be preferred since the same circuit feeds 3 bedrooms.

From my reading over at Leviton, it would seemed that AFCI Receptacle have circuitry specifically designed to reduce the chance of shorts... whereas a GFI is used to reduce shocks from a poor ground or near water surfaces...

I'm not worried so much about shocks... I'm thinking more about shorts and a possible poor ground that wouldn't trip the breaker

Thanks, I think I know my answer just trying to be clear.

__________________

Last edited by curtish; 02-10-2014 at 03:33 PM. Reason: Clarification
curtish is offline  
 
Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 02-11-2014, 09:05 AM  
Wuzzat?
Banned
 
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 2,328
Liked 167 Times on 154 Posts
Likes Given: 94

Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by curtish View Post
I was considering a Outlet AFCI Receptacle...
If you can get such a thing I'd prefer that over a breaker because it will be much easier to troubleshoot.

An arc is supposed to be a fourth state of matter: plasma, as distinguished from solid, liquid or gas.
These gadgets are supposed to distinguish between "good" arcs and "bad" arcs. Practically what this means is that this device will be telling you when to replace your arc-producing appliances and fixtures: motors with brushes and commutators, and switches.
I'd prefer to make my own judgements of when things are worn out.

The accuracy of measuring or testing instruments is supposed to be traceable to the NIST, so I asked them if they have "a standard arc", something to compare to.
They did not reply, probably because it would be bad for business to have official opinions made public about good or bad arcs, false positives/negatives and all kinds of other worms that would climb out of this can.

I doubt that you will find the truth about how reliable these things are and if they significantly improve fire safety over the base rate of fire danger here in the U.S..
If I were close to a Tech Library I'd look in the IEEE Transactions on Power or whatever journal is likely to post a study on this.
Online patent texts may also talk about the shortcomings of earlier AFCI designs.
__________________
Wuzzat? is offline  
 
Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 02-11-2014, 10:11 AM  
nealtw
Contractor
 
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: vancouver, b.c.
Posts: 10,230
Liked 840 Times on 751 Posts
Likes Given: 1456

Default

If you were going to protect the wiring with AFCI you would want to change the breakers to include all the wires not just the outlet. With and older house that is likely going to include a new breaker box.

__________________
nealtw is offline  
 
Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 02-11-2014, 11:09 AM  
curtish
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2014
Posts: 3
Default

Sounds like there are no solid believers in AFCI receptacles for older homes... as it would only protect a device plugged into the AFCI outlet and any extension cords for shorts.

Although I'm wanting to shore up my older wiring without rewiring the house, seems like a waste of money unless I can determine where the first outlet of a supply branch is and whether there was "wagon wheel hub" extensions in the house.

I have already run new dedicated 20 amp circuits to bedroom A/Cs and bathrooms. Perhaps I shouldn't worry too much about the other older wiring in the walls.

I think that's correct anyway, perhaps I will just install a GFI as Speedy Petey recommends.

Thanks for the advice.

__________________
curtish is offline  
 
Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 02-11-2014, 11:38 AM  
nealtw
Contractor
 
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: vancouver, b.c.
Posts: 10,230
Liked 840 Times on 751 Posts
Likes Given: 1456

Default

You might spend some time and check the condition of the wires in boxes and map the system then you could intall welll placed gfis.
In an older house you likely have places that you may be concerned about, extention cords and the like then maybe an afci outlet would not be a bad idea.
The other thing to watch for in old house. If you had a short from a wire to cast iron or copper or steel pipe it would be grounded and blow the fuse or breaker, but as time goes by and people change parts of the plumbing to plastic and ground is lost. A pipe could be live for years waiting to kill someone.

__________________
nealtw is offline  
 
Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 02-19-2014, 05:35 AM  
gottodo1
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2013
Posts: 111
Liked 15 Times on 15 Posts
Likes Given: 4

Default

Wuzzat, I'm sure there's information about an Arc. Do you know what AFCI's are certified against, is it an ANSI, ISO etc etc standard? I can find out what the criteria are or at least how they test it if they don't have design criteria.

__________________

10/1/11: Bought the perfect house;
11/1/12: 10k & 200 hours
08/1/13: 30k & 400 hours into the perfect house
12/1/13: 35k & 500 hours
02/1/14: 37k & 550 hours
08/18/14: 38k & 650 hours it's starting to come together or maybe I'm coming apart

gottodo1 is offline  
 
Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 02-19-2014, 07:48 AM  
Wuzzat?
Banned
 
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 2,328
Liked 167 Times on 154 Posts
Likes Given: 94

Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by gottodo1 View Post
Wuzzat, I'm sure there's information about an Arc. Do you know what AFCI's are certified against, is it an ANSI, ISO etc etc standard? I can find out what the criteria are or at least how they test it if they don't have design criteria.
I was unable to find it.
And as I recall, even the online patents that I searched did not shed much light on exactly how their "signature analysis" is supposed to work. The maker can always claim a Proprietary Method.

Surely at the end of the assembly line these devices are tested, go/no-go, before sold. I'd hope they are tested against bad arcs and good arcs, but I'd like to see that test setup. And how closely do the test arcs match the real world?

And it's not just bad arcs. If you know some programming languages, apparently AFCIs work according to
IF (more than 5A flowing AND bad arc) THEN trip ELSE (don't bother the home owner).
The current flow is another variable in this arc detection strategy.

More generally, and knowing about this
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitivity_and_specificity
as a limit on how well these things can possibly work, I'd like to see the numbers for AFCIs. Numbers are harder to spin.

Let's say you have a genuine bad arc inside a lamp switch.
Well, the switch is housed in a fire resistant shell and a bad switch will make itself known with how the bulb behaves.
So how many house fires did we have before these things and how many do we have now?

With GFCIs there is probably a bias in favor of tripping if the thing is in doubt. I've never heard complaints about a GFCI not tripping and the person continuing to get a shock.


__________________

Last edited by Wuzzat?; 02-19-2014 at 09:52 AM.
Wuzzat? is offline  
 
Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Reply


Quick Reply
Message:
Options

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter DIY Home Repair Forum Replies Last Post
When do I need an AFCI or GFCI? drewdin Electrical and Wiring 6 12-23-2013 11:05 AM
GFCI outlets vs GFCI breakers Dzarate29 Electrical and Wiring 6 11-01-2013 11:32 AM
15 or 20 amp GFCI receptacle? SBay_ecologist Electrical and Wiring 22 06-12-2013 10:02 AM
GFCI receptacle? sdupp Electrical and Wiring 3 01-27-2012 01:38 PM
Installing a new receptacle help! Rehdarh Electrical and Wiring 3 09-04-2009 06:33 PM