LED Bulb vs Retrofit kit
- Thread starter user 4883
- Start date
Help Support House Repair Talk:
nealtw
Contractor retired
Bulbs are cheaper.
beachguy005
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 25, 2012
- Messages
- 844
- Reaction score
- 311
I know some hotel owners that put the retrofit units in all their rooms because the screw in type get stolen and the retros don't. I like the cleaner look of the lens also.
slownsteady
Well-Known Member
Why change fixtures or mess with adapters when you can just screw in a bulb? Hopefully, any houseguest I may have will leave them alone.
From what I've read heat is not an issue with halogen or incandescent bulbs but will shorten the life of an LED bulb. The retro kits have heat sinks to help with this problem and the new trim ring design with perimeter diode placement makes them more attractive than an exposed bulb in a can. I guess more homework is in order to figure out if the extra money is worth the reasons for the kit.
I installed dimmable LED bulbs in my bonus room cans because they were existing with trim rings already in place. If I were installing new can lights I'd forgo the can and install these on a regular ceiling box. http://www.homedepot.com/p/Halo-5-i...isk-Light-80-CRI-3000K-SLD606830WHR/204732243
No need to install a can saving a lot of money in the process, a regular ceiling box is all that is required making them great for areas with limited height above the drywall.
No need to install a can saving a lot of money in the process, a regular ceiling box is all that is required making them great for areas with limited height above the drywall.
Home Depot has them: http://www.homedepot.com/p/Philips-...od-Light-Bulb-435016/205213868#specifications
Color conversions: http://www.seesmartled.com/kb/choosing_color_temperature/
Only 800 lumens but much cheaper than the Home Depot product: http://www.lowes.com/pd_592639-3-78...=1¤tURL=?Ntt=led+light+bulbs&facetInfo=
This site might get you close to what you're looking for. https://www.1000bulbs.com/
Color conversions: http://www.seesmartled.com/kb/choosing_color_temperature/
Only 800 lumens but much cheaper than the Home Depot product: http://www.lowes.com/pd_592639-3-78...=1¤tURL=?Ntt=led+light+bulbs&facetInfo=
This site might get you close to what you're looking for. https://www.1000bulbs.com/
Thanks guys. After doing some more homework, this is what I decided on.
http://www.menards.com/main/p-2428486.htm
I managed to snag these at $25/ea.
http://www.menards.com/main/p-2428486.htm
I managed to snag these at $25/ea.
Just a list from personal experience:
Pro Retro-fit trim:
You get a nice looking new trim ring instead of keeping the old one that may look a bit dingy
The metal of the can is no longer visible due to the new trim ring
I feel like the light is actually a bit brighter/more even
Life span is generally longer
Against Retro-fit:
Cost is generally higher, but you are getting a trim ring out of the deal as well
When one goes out 2 or more years from now you may not find an exact replacement as style/technology is changing almost daily now
Pro LED Bulb:
Easier/Faster
Cheaper
More likely to be able to find one that's similar when one goes out
Looks more like a standard incandescent bulb (may also be negative depending how you look at that)
No need to replace trim ring
Against LED Bulb:
Bulbs typically have a shorter life span
Old, sometimes ugly/dingy trims stay in place
Again this is mostly opinion but a lot of this is experience based on my own house and how my customers have commented. Hopefully you find it at least a bit helpful.
-Lucas
Pro Retro-fit trim:
You get a nice looking new trim ring instead of keeping the old one that may look a bit dingy
The metal of the can is no longer visible due to the new trim ring
I feel like the light is actually a bit brighter/more even
Life span is generally longer
Against Retro-fit:
Cost is generally higher, but you are getting a trim ring out of the deal as well
When one goes out 2 or more years from now you may not find an exact replacement as style/technology is changing almost daily now
Pro LED Bulb:
Easier/Faster
Cheaper
More likely to be able to find one that's similar when one goes out
Looks more like a standard incandescent bulb (may also be negative depending how you look at that)
No need to replace trim ring
Against LED Bulb:
Bulbs typically have a shorter life span
Old, sometimes ugly/dingy trims stay in place
Again this is mostly opinion but a lot of this is experience based on my own house and how my customers have commented. Hopefully you find it at least a bit helpful.
-Lucas
Last edited:
slownsteady
Well-Known Member
Good summary, and welcome!
