Is it on a switch??
If the disposal is on a switch, then it could only trip the gfi not the breaker, if the switch is in the off position. Was the disposal existing, or did he wire this in? Or is everything electrical exactly as before new counter tops, like all the plugs, and the disposal switch? Your looking at everything that was "touched". Let us know, good luck.....
See my work-Check out my album. "Git 'Er Done":D