Welcome Chris...I'm hoping when you changed the thermostat you found some 18ga low voltage wire hooked to it? Five heaters should be on a relay in a closet or attic, and you probably had to turn off two or three breakers before they all shut off? I am just guessin here, maybe the relay is stuck, closed, (failed) let us know what you found out, with these things....
See my work-Check out my album. "Git 'Er Done":D