Light switch sparked and now several things don't work

House Repair Talk

Help Support House Repair Talk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Shane Helm

New Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2019
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Location
Memphis, TN
IMG_20190403_232553177.jpg Hello, the fan and fan light in my kitchen quit working yesterday. Everything else was working. I wanted to pull of the faceplate of the switch just to look to see the switch. I live in a 107 year old house and this switch is probably at least 30 years old. When I was pulling off the faceplate only it caused a spark and then several other things on that line quit working. The refrigerator outlet and the light above the stove and one other outlet. I turned off the power and pulled the switch all the way out. My question is should I replace the switch? What else could have caused the other lines to go out.
I included a picture of what the switch looks like. Thanks for any help!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If other things stopped working, that would suggest that you created a short, and the circuit breaker kicked off, just as it should. The likely cause is a loose wire. Switches don't usually go bad, but, since they only cost a few dollars, you may wish to consider replacing it.

Regardless, I would remove all 3 switches, and make sure that the wires connected to them are tight. Thone wires should be connected to the switch under the screws, and NOT in the "backstabs" where they are pushed into a hole in the back of the switch. Backstabs are known to fail frequently.
 
Step ONE! Stop trying to work the devices live. Even experienced electricians do not do that unless it is absolutely unavoidable! Remove the fuse or turn off the circuit breaker that powers that circuit before doing any more work.

If there is anyone else present that you aren't "lead pipe" sure would never mess with the circuit's fuse or breaker then remove it and remove any spares that they might use to replace it and take those with you until you are ready to re-energize the circuit. This is seldom an issue in single family homes but it is a problem in multi-dwelling buildings were the panel is not within the unit it serves.

By the burn marks on the brass terminal with the red wire on it I would guess that you caught the edge of the adjacent dimmer switch when you were pulling the the cover plate of the box. When the device; in your case the double stack switch; will not sit firmly on the box face and still fit tightly in the face plate then the installer may have used the face plate to hold the double stack switch in place. You remove the face plate and the double stack switch moves so that its terminal touches the heat sink fin of the adjacent dimmer. PIFT the circuit shorts to ground and the Over Current Protective Device (OCPD); fuse or circuit breaker; opens the circuit and clears the fault before arcing can generate enough heat to do more damage or kindle a fire.

BE AWARE THAT THE OCPD WILL PASS MORE THAN ENOUGH CURRENT TO TAKE YOUR LIFE; that only takes 30 milliamperes which is only 3 hundredths of an ampere; prior to opening the circuit. STOP WORKING ELECTRICAL CIRCUITS WHILE THEY ARE STILL ENERGIZED. Am I repeating myself? Why yes I am. In addition to having worked as an electrician for almost 50 years I also served as a Firefighter/ Rescuer (EMT) for 45 years. I have run many calls for electric shock and more than 1 of them had resulted in Electrocution. In 2 cases we had to wait for the Coroner's staff while surrounded by a greiving family. That does tend to make one a little touchy on the issue of live work!

Check that the terminal screws on the double switch are tight but use only your wrist and not your forearm when checking. You need to avoid stripping the threads out of the the plates into which the screws are mounted. Wrap the whole switch in 3 layers of electrical tape under the mounting screws. Remove the mounting screws before taping. Calculate the watts of lighting that are controlled by the dimmer switch and if it is less than half the maximum capacity that is marked on the face of the dimmer then you can break off the fins on that side to give yourself room to safely reinstall the double stack switch. If you want the extra protection against faulting it again then buy an plastic electrical box extender.
accessories-be1-2-64_1000.jpg

Install the box extender right up against the front of the box because in this case it is serving as an insulated divider between the two devices and not to actually extend the box. You will have to install that right against the edge of the adjacent dimmer switch and it will be a challenge to make it fit. If the mounting screws still aren't tight enough to hold the double stack switch still then by a box spacer of the appropriate thickness and mount it behind the mounting ears of the box extender so that when the double stack switch is installed it will be held tightly in place.

receptxtenders-boxes-brackets-00004-64_1000.jpg


Now you can actually try to find the open connection which stopped the ceiling fan from working. The bad news is that many ceiling fans are not well designed so as to facilitate checking the connections with the ceiling fan still mounted. If you remove the ceiling fan you will have opened the splices which are the most likely culprits to have failed because of the vibration caused by the fan they supply.

If you have any more questions please ask. Oh and one last thing. DON' WORK THE CIRCUIT HOT!

--
Tom Horne
 
wrap the switch and/or outlet with electrical tape to cover the lugs to prevent a problem with accidental contact/shorting.
 
Back
Top